ADVANTAGES AND LIMITATIONS OF THE FCM
What distinguishes FCM from other
analytical and preparative techniques is that it combines the
following five essential characteristics: quantitative analysis,
detection sensitivity, speed, multiparameter analysis cell by
cell, sorting.
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS
It is a major advantage compared
to current optical microscopy to be able to quantify the observed
parameters. Indeed, with a microscope, it is difficult to classify
cells in more than four categories according to their
fluorescence: "negative", "weak", "medium", "strong". A cytometer
with a logarithmic amplifier allows the rigorous quantification of
each optical criterion over a range of 1 to several million
arbitrary fluorescence units. But the number of parameters
involved in any FCM analysis (optical settings, fluorochromes,
markers) imposes, within the framework of an absolute
quantification, the use of calibrated standards (fluorescent beads
for example).
DETECTION SENSITIVITY
In immunofluorescence, it is
possible to discern from the background a population of lymphoid
cells carrying about 1000 antigenic determinants per cell.
WORKING SPEED
The average analysis speed of a
cytometer is 10,000 cells per second, although it is possible on
modern instruments to reliably analyze up to 100,000 events per
second on several parameters. In a few seconds, the statistical
significance of the count is much higher than that obtained
conventionally by an optical microscope, even for a subpopulation
of cells in the minority.
SIMULTANEOUS ANALYSIS OF SEVERAL PARAMETERS
CMF offers the possibility to work
simultaneously on several parameters, which allows to measure, for
example, ten or twenty parameters simultaneously on a lymphocyte
population of blood or marrow. No other method, either
physico-chemical (gradient centrifugation, elutriation) or
immunological (panning, columns, rosettes) offers this
versatility.
The new spectral analyzers are capable of measuring up to 40
simultaneous fluorescences in addition to 3 morphology parameters.
SORTING OF CELLS
Cells can be isolated with purity
levels above 99%. These cells can be recultured. However, one
should not forget the relative slowness of the sorting: to obtain
106 cells from a population initially representing 1%
of the starting population, it would take a long time (9 hours and
15 minutes) if the cells are very fragile, for example, whereas it
takes only one hour and 10 minutes if they are small and resistant
(Table 3). The high purity of populations sorted by CMF can
therefore only be achieved at the cost of a serious limitation of
the number of cells collected and constant critical monitoring
during separation.
Nozzle diameter
|
130
|
100
|
85
|
70
|
Pressure Psi (1atm=14,7 Psi)
|
10
|
25
|
45
|
70
|
Fréquency (KHz)
|
11
|
34
|
49
|
90
|
Maximum speed (cells per second)
|
3000
|
7000
|
11000
|
24000
|
Cells analyzed per hour in millions
|
10,8
|
25,2
|
39,6
|
86,4
|
Time to sort 1 million cells representing 1% of the
total
(if sorting efficiency is 100%)
|
9h15
|
4h
|
2h30
|
1h10
|
Table 3 : Sorting constraints:
The diameter of the nozzle must be 3 to 5 times the size of
the cells. Fragile cells must be sorted at low pressure.